1. The Nice treaty is flawed. However,the EU constitution proposal multiplies these flaws. It's a bianco cheque for power to the most powerful lobbying group in Brussells: the bureaucracy.

2. The fact that both José Bové and Le Pen (and extremist idiots of all kinds) are against it, forms no logical basis to conclude that the constitution is good. This is a manipulative, not a logical argument.

3. If it were true and granted that the Brussells centre is smarter and more enlightened that national governments, nobody would be more convinced Eurofederalist than myself. In fact, I believe that competition of nation states is more efficient system than the EU.

4. If for nothing else, manipulative arguments by euroenthusiasts have been so foul and sinister that I would vote NO (if I had the chance) just for the sake of protest against psychological manipulation.